Mind Network - Samuel Solomon

Motivation for Quantum Mechanics

Photoelectric effect
          Quantum Mechanics was not an intuitive leap that physicists made one day. Rather, it was a cumulative ansatz (guess) to a series of unexplained experiments in an era of increasing experimental accuracy. One such experiment was the photoelectric effect. The photoelectric effect is simple. When high energy light is shined on a metal, electrons are ejected off (recorded as a current through a wire). In our classical picture, light is just a continuous wave.
The Photoelectric Effect
Ionization of an electron
On the figure on the left:
       1. High energy light is shined onto a metal surface (anode: as it will be oxidized (loose electrons) in this scenario)
       2. The electrons are ejected from the anode and are quickly taken up by the cathode metal (which is reduced)
       3. The ammeter measures the current. A voltmeter can also be placed to measure the potential difference.
       4. The anode is then grounded (given back its electrons) through the same wire.

On the figure on the right:
       1. Light of some energy E comes in.
       2. It used some of its energy to eject the bound electron. Total energy loss is the ionization energy (IE) of electron.
       3. The free electron is ejected and has the remaining energy of the photon, which is = E - IE

          Altogether, this experiment makes intuitive sense. Light, like all species in this world, has energy. If it hits an electron in the right place it can transfer some of its energy to the electron and eject the electron off. The not intuitive part comes when one starts to vary some of the parameters of this experiment. Let us analyze those.

Experimental Variations:
       1. Below a certain frequency of light, no electrons are ejected regardless of the intensity of light (number of particles).
              a. Classical Mechanics: Light is a continuous wave. Greater intensity = more particles = more energy (WRONG)
              b. Quantum Mechanics: The energy of light relates to frequency and cannot be a continuous spectrum of particles.

          The classical picture has light continuously hitting the electron. However, then if you increase the number of particles, then more would hit the electron at the exact same time. Since this is not experimentally observed, the quantum picture has light in discrete bunches. Adding more particles would not mean that all light particles hit the same electron. In fact, it is very unlikely to have two light particles hitting the exact same location at once.

The classical theory of light as a wave does not hold in this experiment. Therefore, light cannot be a classical wave.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Quantum Mechanics I
    • Introduction to Waves (The Wave Equation)
    • Introduction to Waves (The Wave Function)
    • Motivation for Quantum Mechanics (Photoelectric effect)
    • Motivation for Quantum Mechanics (Compton Scattering)
    • Motivation for Quantum Mechanics (Black Body Radiation)
    • Bohr Model of the Atom
    • Wave-Particle Duality (The Wave Function Motivation)
    • Problems with the Wave Function
    • Introduction to Quantum Operators (The Formalism)
    • Introduction to Dirac Notation
    • Introduction to Quantum Operators (The Hermitian and the Adjoint)
    • Introduction to Commutation
    • Expectation Values of Operators
    • Quantum Uncertainty (Defining Uncertainty)
    • Quantum Uncertainty (Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle)
    • The Schrödinger Equation (The "Derivation")
    • The Schrödinger Equation (How to use it)
    • No Degeneracy in 1-Dimension
    • Parity Operator
    • Quantum Mechanics' Core Postulates
    • Free Particle (In a Vacuum)
    • Particle in a Box (Infinite Square Well)
    • Bound States (The Mathematical Setup)
    • Bound States (The Shooting Method)
    • Bound States (Patching Solutions Together)
    • Patching Solutions (Finite, Infinite, and Delta Function Potentials)
    • Delta Function Potential Well
    • Scatter States (A Touch on Dispersion)
    • Scatter States (Reflection, Transmission, Probability Current)
    • Scatter States (Worked Example)
    • Scatter States (Elastic Collision)
    • Quantum Tunneling (Constant Potential)
    • Quantum Tunneling (Changing Potential)
    • Quantum Tunneling (Alpha Decay Example)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Classical Mechanics Analogue)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Brute Force Solution)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Ladder Operators)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Expectation Values)
    • Bringing Quantum to 3D (Cartesian Coordinates)
    • Free Particle
    • Infinite Cubic Well (3D Particle in a Box)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator
    • Schrödinger Equation (Spherical Coordinates)
    • Angular Momentum (Experiments)
    • Angular Momentum (Operators)
    • Angular Momentum (Ladder Operators)
    • Schrödinger Equation (Spherical Symmetric Potential)
    • Infinite Spherical Well (Radial Solution)
    • One Electron Atom (Radial Solution for S-orbital)
    • Hydrogen Atom (Angular Solution; Spherically Symmetric)
    • Hydrogen Atom (Radial Solution; Any Orbital)
    • Hydrogen atom (Recap)
  • Quantum Mechanics II
  • Nuclear Fusion
    • Introduction to Fission (Energy Extraction)
    • Introduction to Fusion (Applications and Challenges)
    • Choosing Fusion Reactants
  • Special Relativity
    • Terminology and Notation
    • Galilean Transformation
  • Statistical Thermodynamics
  • Chemical Thermodynamics
  • Ionization Radiation
  • Multivariable Calculus
    • Vectors
    • Dot Product
    • Cross Product
    • Rotating Vectors
    • Level Curves
    • Gradients
    • Directional Derivatives
  • Differential Equations
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Quantum Mechanics I
    • Introduction to Waves (The Wave Equation)
    • Introduction to Waves (The Wave Function)
    • Motivation for Quantum Mechanics (Photoelectric effect)
    • Motivation for Quantum Mechanics (Compton Scattering)
    • Motivation for Quantum Mechanics (Black Body Radiation)
    • Bohr Model of the Atom
    • Wave-Particle Duality (The Wave Function Motivation)
    • Problems with the Wave Function
    • Introduction to Quantum Operators (The Formalism)
    • Introduction to Dirac Notation
    • Introduction to Quantum Operators (The Hermitian and the Adjoint)
    • Introduction to Commutation
    • Expectation Values of Operators
    • Quantum Uncertainty (Defining Uncertainty)
    • Quantum Uncertainty (Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle)
    • The Schrödinger Equation (The "Derivation")
    • The Schrödinger Equation (How to use it)
    • No Degeneracy in 1-Dimension
    • Parity Operator
    • Quantum Mechanics' Core Postulates
    • Free Particle (In a Vacuum)
    • Particle in a Box (Infinite Square Well)
    • Bound States (The Mathematical Setup)
    • Bound States (The Shooting Method)
    • Bound States (Patching Solutions Together)
    • Patching Solutions (Finite, Infinite, and Delta Function Potentials)
    • Delta Function Potential Well
    • Scatter States (A Touch on Dispersion)
    • Scatter States (Reflection, Transmission, Probability Current)
    • Scatter States (Worked Example)
    • Scatter States (Elastic Collision)
    • Quantum Tunneling (Constant Potential)
    • Quantum Tunneling (Changing Potential)
    • Quantum Tunneling (Alpha Decay Example)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Classical Mechanics Analogue)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Brute Force Solution)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Ladder Operators)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Expectation Values)
    • Bringing Quantum to 3D (Cartesian Coordinates)
    • Free Particle
    • Infinite Cubic Well (3D Particle in a Box)
    • Quantum Harmonic Oscillator
    • Schrödinger Equation (Spherical Coordinates)
    • Angular Momentum (Experiments)
    • Angular Momentum (Operators)
    • Angular Momentum (Ladder Operators)
    • Schrödinger Equation (Spherical Symmetric Potential)
    • Infinite Spherical Well (Radial Solution)
    • One Electron Atom (Radial Solution for S-orbital)
    • Hydrogen Atom (Angular Solution; Spherically Symmetric)
    • Hydrogen Atom (Radial Solution; Any Orbital)
    • Hydrogen atom (Recap)
  • Quantum Mechanics II
  • Nuclear Fusion
    • Introduction to Fission (Energy Extraction)
    • Introduction to Fusion (Applications and Challenges)
    • Choosing Fusion Reactants
  • Special Relativity
    • Terminology and Notation
    • Galilean Transformation
  • Statistical Thermodynamics
  • Chemical Thermodynamics
  • Ionization Radiation
  • Multivariable Calculus
    • Vectors
    • Dot Product
    • Cross Product
    • Rotating Vectors
    • Level Curves
    • Gradients
    • Directional Derivatives
  • Differential Equations
  • Contact